I don’t think I’ve ever believed in Santa Claus. That clichéd moment where someone accidentally spills the beans and crushes innocent children’s imaginations never happened to me. Perhaps, because when I was growing up we exchanged gifts on three king’s day instead of Christmas. This is why I will always remember my first Christmas in the states. That, and because it’s the first time I remember noticing color for the first time.
My mom and my dad took my sisters and I to a toy store for our first Christmas. They turned to us and said “go pick out what you want us, we mean Santa, to bring to you! (See, my parents had no respect for Santa Claus)” They set us loose and I walked around every aisle looking for the perfect doll. I ran past the Barbie aisle, I never liked her anyway, looked at all the easy bake ovens and all the board games. There was nothing that called my name. That is, until I saw the most perfect doll. She had on a big bow on her head and a microphone attached to her hand. I was convinced I was going to be a superstar and that doll and I were a match made in heaven. I grabbed her and ran to my parents.
My mom took one look at the doll in my hand and ordered to return it and grab a different one. Why? Because much to my mother’s horror I had grabbed the black doll and that was unacceptable.
“But, that’s the one I want” I told her lips quivering.
“Why don’t you get this one, this one is pretty” (hands me the white doll)
I hold on to my doll tighter and in that moment, in the middle of the store, I start to cry. My mother, who has never been one for scenes, tries to get me to stop. She gives me “the look” and whispers “Stop it!” through her teeth. I am inconsolable. How am I going to put on shows without my singing doll?! Finally, my father puts a stop to it and says I can get whatever doll I want. My mom is annoyed, my father just wanted me to stop throwing a tantrum and I got to go home happy.
Why am I telling this story?
A few months ago there was an article on New Latina called “I’m white, my daughter is Latina and I buy black dolls.” I told this story in the comments sections and was contacted by Dash Harris about a documentary depicting the African diaspora in Latin America and its influence on the culture with a focus on colorism and racism among Latinos. I met up with her to film my own experience. Mostly, I let her know my confusion because my family is a veritable rainbow coalition. We’re all different shades and yet there are still comments and situations that remind me of that doll story to this day.
What do you think about the topic? Any similar experience?
You can learn more and support Dash’s documentary by clicking the link.
Ps. I wanted to show a picture of my family but I’m pretty sure they don’t want to be posted all over the internet. Instead, I have drawn you a picture! Enjoy.


Are you the one in the red dress? Lol.
I remember always being called the “blanquita” of my immediate family. My sister, mom, father, and brother are all darker than me, so I almost prided myself in being the lighter one. Even recently, when I went to Miami, my uncles wife made a comment that I had become much darker than I was as a child. I heard myself defending my bronzer skin color. “It’s the sun!” and “I just got back from Puerto Rico!” as if her commentary was an insult. Comes to show that there are deep seated issues with color in all of us.
Glad that you are part of the documentary! See what leaving great comments on blogs does for engagement?
haha yes that’s me in the red dress. How did you know?!
You’re definitely right about the deep seeded issues. I think every culture has some sort of color complex.
I love the family portrait! <3
I often wondered about the choosing of dolls, do we get them because we identify with them? There wasn't a brown baby doll until I was too old for dolls (well we had a lot of Black and White Barbie Dolls), then American Girl company came in with multicultural dolls.
I am happy that there will be a new documentary on it. I know that PBS had the special Black in Latin America earlier this year, so this is definitely a great topic to discuss.
1) I found out there was no Santa because I woke up in the middle of the night to my dad shouting in the living room “How are we going to fit all these fucking presents under the tree?!” I wandered out, “Dad?
”
2) I picked out the American Girl doll Addy (the only black doll). My parents said “ok!” Sorry your mom wasn’t as supportive of your singing doll.
It’s true that many cultures have issues about color. Your story is remarkable because, as doll tests have shown, many black girls would NOT have chosen the black doll. I hate to admit that until I read further, I thought you had chosen the white doll because past experience has told me that’s what little girls choose. It’s interesting that there was something in you that refused to give up the black doll, even with your mother urging you to. That story is definitely worth being featured in a documentary. I can’t wait to see it.
Peace,
SLW